RIAA Says Google is Still Promoting Piracy

February 24th, 2013
Goto comments Leave a comment

In August of 2012, Google had made an agreement to be a little more restricting on their search results showing websites that engage in piracy and copyright infringement. About 18 months later, this well-appreciated search engine has yet to do anything towards “cracking down.” Read on for more details.

RIAA logo

Amit Singhal, the senior vice president of engineering at Google, said that “sites with high numbers of removal notices may appear lower in our results.” Chief executive Geoff Taylor also stated:

We have argued for some time that the fact that certain websites are subject to very high numbers of DMCA notifications, because they feature a large amount of illegal content, should be reflected in lower search rankings. Consumers overwhelmingly want and expect the top search results for entertainment content to feature legal, licensed services. We will look carefully at how much impact this change will have in practice, but we welcome the announcement from Google and will be pressing other search engines to follow suit.

However, in contradiction to these statements the Recording Industry Association of America says that the site still presents the serial infringers pretty high in search results. The auto-completion feature also leads to the sites most known for piracy. RIAA’s EVP and general counsel, Steven Marks, said the following in relation to this incident:

Unfortunately, our initial analysis concludes that so far Google’s pledge six months ago to demote pirate sites remains unfulfilled. Searches for popular music continue to yield results that emphasize illegal sites at the expense of legitimate services, which are often relegated to later pages. And Google’s auto-complete function continues to lead users to many of those same illicit sites.

In all fairness, Google did say that they will only enforce their limitations on sites that are properly labeled as violating copyright laws by the rights’ owner themselves. Electronic Frontier Foundation’s Julie Samuels and Mitch Soltz offered:

Takedown requests are nothing more than accusations of copyright infringement. No court or other umpire confirms that the accusations are valid (although copyright owners can be liable for bad-faith accusations). Demoting search results – effectively telling the searcher that these are not the websites you’re looking for – based on accusations alone gives copyright owners one more bit of control over what we see, hear, and read.

Google users take advantage of the site for the high volume of relevant results to their questions. With so much information floating around in the could, any Internet user will find the answers they are looking for. According to the RIAA, Google should have still gone in and enforced some preventative measures to make sure that the users don’t find what they are looking for. By default, this apparently means that Google is promoting piracy. In the words of TG Daily, “There’s just no pleasing some people.”

Search for Google albums on Amazon

By Antoinette Ochoa Posted in News , ,

Related RIAA Content:

Limewire Shuts Down
RIAA to Change Gold and Platinum Rules Due to Jay-Z’s New Album Magna Carta Holy Grail
Music Industry Revenues Increase For First Time in 13 Years
RIAA Says Google is Still Promoting Piracy
College Student Will Be Forced to Pay $675,000 For Illegally Downloading 30 Songs
RIAA Fires Back at Minnesota P2P Martyr
RIAA Ramps Up Fight Against Torrents
Limewire Pays $105 Million to RIAA Out of Court
RIAA Makes Moves Threatening Net Neutrality

Related Google Content:

Google Earth has a Morrissey Easter Egg
Controversy Unravels After Universal Pulls Megaupload Video From YouTube
Google Reportedly Set to Launch Music Download Service
Songza Bought By Google
MySpace Up For Sale; Rumors That Google Is Trying Buy
Google Excludes Rap Genius From Top Search Results
Google Launches Music-Streaming Radio Google Play Music All Access

Top Story
Google Music Launches Cloud Storage Service

Related piracy Content:

Universal Music Sparks Piracy Witch Hunt Aimed at Hip Hop Sites and Blogs