All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA 2012 Day 2 (The Afghan Whigs, The Roots, Jose Gonzalez, Dirty Three and more)

September 23rd, 2012
Goto comments Leave a comment

The 2012 version of I’ll Be Your Mirror USA—All Tomorrow’s Parties’ grand urban festival experiment on the Lower East Side of New York City—continued on Saturday, September 22. The roster promised the weekend’s largest selection of performers and activities, including curator Greg Dulli and his partners in The Afghan Whigs. If ever there was a time for this particular incarnation of IBYM to step up and maintain ATP’s rep as a harbinger of good taste, to rock the party and bring the party to rock, this was probably it.


The day kicked off with the first true tests of the festival’s second stage, under the edge of an overpass of the FDR Drive. Friday’s comedians seemed weirded out by the setting, yet their voice-only performances never really challenged the soundboard crew. Music from electronic duo Emeralds kicked off Saturday more or less OK. The drones in their vintage grooves sometimes got a little muddied and tuneless in the mix, but their underlying synth loops carried the day. Emeralds played for 45 minutes without a break, leading the crowd through what seemed like just three distinct head-nodders suggesting both Kraftwerk’s early motorik music and modern dance-punks !!!.



Proto-riot grrrl group Scrawl followed Emeralds under the sun and highway. The Ohio trio are the kind of festival signing that helped establish ATP as the mad scientists of booking: an influential, long-lamented artist to make the oldheads go crazy and the young kids go, “Oh, they did that?” It’s even better if such an act can still bring the hammer down on a crowd, and despite looking the part of Midwestern soccer moms the guitar-bass core of Marcy Mays and Sue Harshe did just that. Their 45-minute slot, reaching all the way back to first album Plus, Also, Too from 1987, sounded a lot like a favorite history lesson of bands like Sleater-Kinney and The Breeders.




High-end literature and culture imprint Lapham’s Quarterly returned to ATP with more of their signature roundtables and events. Greg Dulli actually put together a book list for festival attendees as part of his curation, and LQ helped promote some of the selections with speakers on topics related to particular plots and characters. Notable among these guests were Evan Michelson and Mike Zohn, proprietors of the Lower East Side curiosity shop Obscura Antiques & Oddities featured on Discovery Channel’s Oddities. They used Katherine Dunn’s Geek Love to riff on weirdness from sideshow memorabilia to purposeful amputations. Crowds for these diversions may have been small, but never let it be said that ATP and their supporters aren’t an intellectually curious bunch.


Back under the FDR, Brooklynite Charles Bradley cemented his case as the best understudy James Brown never requested. Supported by The Extraordinaires, yet another killer Daptone Records all-star band, Bradley was the Poor Man’s Hardest Working Man in Show Business (which makes sense, considering his past nomadic life). He was all funk screeches and mic stand tricks, shifty dancing and costume changes. He even covered “Gonna Have a Funky Good Time,” for heaven’s sake. His shit didn’t fit, and his moves didn’t always groove, but damned if his efforts and his own music (”This Love Ain’t Big Enough for the Two of Us”) didn’t push the crowd toward rapture.





Now, a confession: Your author never really latched onto the catalog of Dirty Three, Warren Ellis’ self-pleasuring violin vehicle when he’s not a Bad Seed alongside Nick Cave. It must not translate very well—maybe it’s the constraints of studio equipment and space, finite songs to place in a finite album length—because watching them is a different beast altogether. Ellis seems to position his violin as a madman’s guitar and Mick Turner’s guitar more as the bass, a rhythmic foundation alongside Jim White’s rolling drums. He screams through instrumentals, roaming the stage and karate-kicking like David Lee Roth, giving long-winded and philosophical intros to (possibly fake?) song titles. And yet, Dirty Three manage not just manic jams but dramatic, even sad power. They’re crowd favorites wherever ATP touches down, and you have to see them to understand why.




Then you have this quintet with two drummers, The Dirtbombs, Detroit rockers with a fetish for their city’s musical history. A lot of who and what The Dirtbombs are will no doubt surprise new listeners. It took a few songs for them to shake off the garage grunge and let some hard soul shine through. They shifted from songs about trying love (”Chains of Love”) to failed bravado (”Candy Ass”) with help from pogoing blues instrumentals and even one of their Party Store covers of old-school techno, Inner City’s “Good Life.” Thanks to the end of Dirty Three’s set and dinnertime among the boutique food trucks, the biggest crowd of the day saw Mick Collins powering through squealing Hendrix-isms as Pat Pentano and Ben Blackwell tried to break through their skins. The fans ate it up, as it were.




Sadly, what may have been the first real dud set of the weekend followed soon thereafter. Blues Funeral is the latest album from The Mark Lanegan Band. It’s a really nice slice of gothic soul, and it puts the band on the wrong end of the expectations with which Dirty Three deal. Lanegan’s crew put forth dour artistry that’s a rather fine headphone trip but came across lifeless and monochromatic on the main Pier 36 stage. One has to wonder if their mix suffered the most in the converted, cavernous and column-filled super-gym (the pier building is normally home to New York’s installation of Basketball City). Plus, there was no Gutter Twins reunion with Dulli outside of set closer “Methamphetamine Blues,” so do we boo that as well?


Lanegan’s lack of crowd connection helped make Jose Gonzalez’ set stand out in relief that much more. Despite commitments to other performances, activities or food trucks, you simply couldn’t pull yourself away from the most pleasant, downright nicest performance up to this point in the weekend. With his hypnotic finger-picking and lilting, cooing vocals, Gonzalez transmits a serious Richie Havens or early Cat Stevens vibe—maybe even Jack Johnson or Bob Marley, minus the ganja. Backed by cool night air, smoke machines, and blinding stage lights, Gonzalez conjured a little bit of magic under the FDR.



The Afghan Whigs—the first and longest-lasting OMG name on this festival’s bill—brought fans down to earth, and they were more than happy to land not on feathers or a trampoline but the band’s shards of broken relationships. Pros at rock to the Nth power of soul and off the grid as a group for just about ever—no songs in five years, no albums in 14—Greg Dulli and friends had plenty of surprises in store for the crowd, which by now was swollen to headliner capacity. Across a playlist spanning their entire career, The Afghan Whigs reconfigured words spoken to and spoken by women to sad, sometimes sinister ends. There were of course catalog favorites like “66,” “Son of the South,” and “My Curse” (with an appearance by the original vocalist, Scrawl’s Marcy Mays), and then big hits “Gentlemen” and “Debonair.” These eventually gave way to some of their jaw-dropping takes on R&B, including Frank Ocean (”Lovecrimes” and a bit of “Thinking About You”), Gloria Jones (”Tainted Love” attached to “Bulletproof”), and Prince (”Purple Rain”).


So once The Afghan Whigs cleared out, so did a good chunk of the crowd. Their loss, as those who stayed behind caught the antics/majesty of The Roots. The Philadelphia rap crew-turned-house band for Jimmy Fallon went straight apeshit on Pier 36 for a solid 90 minutes. They were pretty much a variety show all their own: generating separate medleys of Beastie Boys cuts and classic rock (Guns ‘n’ Roses, Led Zeppelin, et al.), mashing up Black Thought’s raps with other instrumental tracks, dancing while playing their guitars and sousaphones (!). And talk about endless energy: The Roots in concert have more false finishes than a Chikara wrestling show. You’d think a ?uestlove drum solo or a late “Here I Come”/”The Seed 2.0″ sequence would signal show’s end, but you’d hear “Thank you New York” and the band would start right back up. Which reminds us: Thank you New York, and thank you ATP. Sunday afternoon comes quickly.




All photos by Adam Blyweiss

Search for All Tomorrow's Parties albums on Amazon
Watch Charles Bradley concerts on Qello Concerts:

By Adam Blyweiss Posted in Reviews, Show Reviews , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Related Mark Lanegan Content:

High Fidelity
Soulsavers – Broken
Mark Lanegan Band – Blues Funeral

Soulsavers Enlist Mike Patton and Jason Pierce for New Album
Listen: WhoMadeWho and Mark Lanegan Release Covers of “Deep Black Vanishing Train” and “Below the Cherry Moon” for Charity
Watch: Video for Mark Lanegan Band’s New Song “The Gravedigger’s Song”
Mark Lanegan Releases Tour-Only Christmas Album Dark Mark Does Christmas 2012
LISTEN: Moby and Mark Lanegan Release New Track Titled “The Lonely Night”
LISTEN: Mark Lanegan Releases Cover of “Deepest Shade” by The Twilight Singers
WATCH: Sweet Apple Releases New Video for “Wish You Could Stay a Little Longer” feat. Mark Lanegan
Listen to Mark Lanegan Band’s New Single “The Gravedigger’s Song” + Blues Funeral Album Cover and Track Listing Revealed
Listen: Mad Season Offers New Tracks “Slip Away” and Black Book of Fear Featuring Mark Lanegan
Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Festival Announces 2013 Lineup Including Conor Oberst, Father John Misty, Mark Lanegan and More
The Stooges Announce Release of New Album Without Iggy
Mark Lanegan Band Announces New Album Blues Funeral for February 2012 Release, Features Appearances by Josh Homme and Greg Dulli
Listen: Mark Lanegan and Duke Garwood Release New Track “Black Pudding”
Mark Lanegan Announces Fall 2013 Tour Dates
Mark Lanegan To Begin New Album
The Twilight Singers to Perform Blackberry Belle One Night Only
Listen: Mark Lanegan and Martina Topley-Bird Cover The xx Song “Crystalised”
Listen: Mark Lanegan Covers Tim Hardin’s “Red Balloon”
Box of Stars Announce Sparklehorse Tribute Album Featuring Flaming Lips, Mark Lanegan, Phantogram, and More To Raise Awareness of Mental Health Issues
LISTEN: Mark Lanegan Band Releases New Song “Flood Of The Ocean”
More Details on New Mark Lanegan LP
Listen: Mark Lanegan, Ralph Stanley Cover The Velvet Underground and Captain Beefheart For the Lawless Soundtrack
Mark Lanegan and Duke Garwood Announce Collaboration Album Black Pudding Set For April 2013 Release
Moby Announces New Album Innocents Featuring Collaborations with Mark Lanegan, Wayne Coyne, and More Set for October 2013 Release
Mark Lanegan Announces Best-Of Compilation Has God Seen My Shadow? An Anthology 1989 – 2011
Mark Lanegan Announces New Album Phantom Radio For October 2014 Release
Mark Lanegan and Isobel Campbell Announce US Tour
Soulsavers Announce New Album The Light the Dead See Featuring Vocals By Dave Gahan For May 2012 Release
Watch: John Cale, Mark Lanegan, and Sharon Van Etten Perform Life Along the Borderline: A Tribute to Nico
Mark Lanegan Releases Stream of John Cale Song “I’m Not the Loving Kind” Off New Covers Album Imitations Set for September 2013 Release
Soulsavers Announce Reissue of Their First Album “Tough Guys Don’t Dance” Available October 13th via Bandcamp
Mark Lanegan, Smoke River, Okkervil River and More Record Covers For Tribute Album Reason To Believe – The Songs of Tim Hardin Set for February 2013 Release
LISTEN: Queens of the Stone Age Release Cover of Mark Lanegan’s “100 Days”
WATCH: Martina Topley-Bird, Mark Lanegan, and Warpaint Release Official Video for Cover of “Crystalised” by The xx
WATCH: Mark Lanegan Releases New Video for “Sad Lover”

Mark Lanegan and Duke Garwood – Black Pudding
Mark Lanegan – Imitations
Sweet Apple – The Golden Age of Glitter
Soulsavers – Broken
Soulsavers – It’s Not How Far You Fall, It’s The Way You Land
All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA 2012 Day 2 (The Afghan Whigs, The Roots, Jose Gonzalez, Dirty Three and more)
Mark Lanegan Band – No Bells on Sunday EP

Related All Tomorrow's Parties Content:

Interview: The Album Leaf’s Jimmy LaValle on New EP and All Tomorrow’s Parties

Battles Take A Break From The Studio For Two Live Shows
All Tomorrow’s Parties Festival Curated By Jeff Mangum Pushed Back to March 2012
All Tomorrow’s Parties Announces End of an Era Festival 2013 Lineup, Television to Play Marquee Moon In Its Entirety Weekend 1
All Tomorrow’s Parties Festival NY Announces Line-Up
Medical Issues Cause More Mogwai U.S. Tour Date Postponements
Breeders Reunite To Perform at All Tomorrow’s Parties 2013
The Residents and More Added to ATP Line-Up
Public Enemy, Company Flow Added to ATP Fest Lineup
Buke and Gase Announce New Album General Dome For January 2013 Release
Hot Snakes Announce December 2012 Tour Dates
I’ll Be Your Mirror Festival Acquires Additional Acts and Ticket Option
All Tomorrow’s Parties I’ll Be Your Mirror NJ Moved to New York City
Caribou Offers Vibration Ensemble Live Album for Free Download
All Tomorrow’s Parties The Nightmare Before Christmas 2012 Curated By Shellac Announced
TV on the Radio and Deerhunter To Curate All Tomorrow’s Parties 2013
Jabberwocky Festival Announces Cancellation
All Tomorrow’s Parties 2012 Curated by The National Moved to Pontins Holiday Camp
All Tomorrow’s Parties Announce 2014 Lineup Featuring Portishead, Interpol and More
Newest All Tomorrow’s Parties Event Announced, Godspeed You! Black Emperor, Boris, Boredoms Headline
Jeff Mangum Announces New North American Tour Dates
Slint Set to Perform For First Time In Six Years at ATP – End of An Era Festival 2013

All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA 2012 Day 1 (Frank Ocean, Philip Glass, Tyondai Braxton, Janeane Garofalo and More)
All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA 2012 Day 3 (Godspeed You! Black Emperor, Autolux, The Make-Up and more)

Top Story
Portishead Announce North American October Tour
All Tomorrow’s Parties Presents I’ll Be Your Mirror in New Jersey

Related the Roots Content:

mxdwn Best of SXSW 2012

High Fidelity
The Roots – Undun
Elvis Costello and The Roots – Wise Up Ghost
The Roots – How I Got Over

WATCH: Red Hot Chili Peppers and The Roots Perform Funkadelic’s “Standing on the Verge of Getting It On”
The Roots’ Questlove Waxes Philosophic About Hip Hop
Watch: The Roots Make My Video
Hopscotch Music Festival Announces 2012 Lineup Featuring The Roots and The Jesus and Mary Chain
Black Thought of The Roots Raps The 2013 Oscar Nominees
WATCH: Robin Thicke, Jimmy Fallon, and The Roots Perform G-Rated Version of “Blurred Lines”
Roots Picnic 2014 Lineup Announced Featuring Janelle Monae, Snoop Dogg and More
CounterPoint Music and Arts Festival 2015 Lineup Announced Featuring Zedd, The Roots, and Knife Party
The Roots Get Over New Record Release Date
The Roots Announce New Album Undun Due Out December 6th
Roskilde Festival Announces 2012 Lineup Featuring Bjork, The Roots, Jack White and More
The Roots and Maya Rudolph Team Up to Perform Prince Covers Concert
LISTEN: Elvis Costello & The Roots Release Stream of Single “Walk Us Uptown”
The Roots Almost Done With New Concept Album
Bono Says His Bike Injuries Might Prevent Him from Playing Guitar Ever Again
Free Dirty Projectors Release Digital 7in
The Roots Score Soundtrack to “Night Catches Us”
Hurricane Irene Forces Cancellations of Shows, Festivals on the East Coast
Listen: Hear “Redford,” “Possibility” and “Will to Power” From The Roots’ New Album undun
The Roots and Ben Folds Five to Play 2012 Mountain Jam
The Roots Announce New Album &TYSYC
WATCH: The Roots Cover “Get Lucky” and Rap Over Mario Brothers
WATCH: U2 Perform on The Tonight Show
Essence Festival Announces 2014 Lineup Including Prince, Janelle Monae and The Roots
The Roots, Perry Farrell And Sleigh Bells’ Alexis Krauss Will Play A Tribute Show For Talking Heads’ David Byrne
Get The Roots/John Legend Album For Free
Watch The tUnE-yArDs And The Roots Perform ‘Gangsta’ On Fallon
The Roots Must Clear Music With NBC After Incident on Jimmy Fallon
Watch: Bruce Springsteen and The Roots Perform “E Street Shuffle” Live at the Roskilde Festival
Life Is Good Festival Announces 2013 Lineup Including Hall & Oates, Jack Johnson, The Roots, and More
WATCH: Jimmy Fallon & The Muppets Cover The Band’s “The Weight”
WATCH: Jimmy Fallon And The Roots Fill In For U2 And Cover “Desire”
Special Guests Announced For John Legend and The Roots Live Stream
The Roots Will Release A New Album Before 2012
The Roots Play Out Michelle Bachmann to Fishbone’s “Lyin’s Ass Bitch”
The Roots Announce 6th Annual Roots Picnic 2013 Lineup Featuring Grimes, Macklemore & Ryan Lewis and Naughty by Nature
Elvis Costello & The Roots Announce Release of Collaborative Album Wise Up Ghost Set for September 2013 Release
Elvis Costello & The Roots Announce Spring 2014 Tour Dates
Boston Calling Announce Fall 2014 Festival Lineup Including The National, The Replacements and Nas x The Roots
The Roots and John Legend Release Video
The Roots Sprout Details on Next Album
Watch: The Roots Feat. P.O.R.N. – Stomp
Watch: Nas Performs with The Roots on Late Night With Jimmy Fallon
Watch: Frank Ocean and The Roots Perform “Bad Religion” on Late Night With Jimmy Fallon
Watch: Wu-Tang Clan and the Roots Perform “Six Directions of Boxing” on Jimmy Fallon
WATCH: Major Lazer, Amber Coffman, Dave Longstreth, and The Roots Perform Together On Jimmy Fallon
The Roots Announce New Album…And Then You Shoot Your Cousin for May 2014 Release and Release New Track “When the People Cheer”
WATCH: The Roots Release New Video For “Never”
John Legend and the Roots to Play at the Troubadour (LA) in Support of Collaborative Album
J.Period and Black Thought Set To Record Live Mixtape
The Roots Announce Track Listing and Collaborators For undun Including A Special Track Featuring Sufjan Stevens
MOG SXSW 2012 Day Party Announced Featuring The Roots and Bob Mould
Watch: Fiona Apple and The Roots Cover Paul McCartney & Wings’ “Let Me Roll It”
TV Series Yo Gabba Gabba! to Release Gabba Gabba! Music is Awesome!: Four October 2012 Featuring The Roots, Biz Markie, Metric and More
The Roots to Follow Jimmy Fallon to The Tonight Show
The Roots Streaming Entire New Album on Myspace
The Roots Premiere Video for “Tip the Scale”
Watch: President Barack Obama Slow Jams the News With The Roots and Jimmy Fallon
WATCH: Questlove and Rahzel Perform At Red Bull Music Academy
WATCH: Elvis Costello and The Roots Perform “Walk Us Uptown” on Late Night With Jimmy Fallon

The Roots, Live at the Public Theater
The Roots Live at The Mohawk MOG Party SXSW
The Roots – …And Then You Shoot Your Cousin

Top Story
San Francisco’s Outside Lands Announces Lineup
Bonnaroo 2012 Lineup Announced Featuring Radiohead, Red Hot Chili Peppers and The Beach Boys

Related Jose Gonzalez Content:

High Fidelity
Junip – Junip

Junip Premieres Video for “Always”
Jose Gonzalez-led Junip Announce Free EP
Junip Announces New Record and Tour
José González Announces Spring 2015 Tour Dates
WATCH: Jose Gonzalez Releases New Video For Song “Every Age”
José González Announces New Album Vestiges & Claws For February 2015 Release

Junip, Live at the Troubadour

Related Greg Dulli Content:

The Twilight Singers Return
Greg Dulli Announces Solo Tour
Steve Kilbey and Greg Dulli Announce One-Night Show at The Echo on October 9th
WATCH: The Afghan Whigs Release A New Video For “Lost in the Woods”

The Twilight Singers – Dynamite Steps
The Afghan Whigs – Do to the Beast

Related Dirty Three Content:

Dirty Three Announce Fall 2012 Tour Dates
Mick Turner (Dirty Three) Announces New Album Don’t Tell the Driver For November 2013 Release
Le Guess Who? Festival 2012 Lineup Announced Featuring Fuck Buttons, Dirty Three, Grimes and More

Dirty Three – Toward The Low Sun

Related The Dirtbombs Content:

Dirtbombs Release Companion Album
The Dirtbombs Do Detroit Techno

Related I'll Be Your Mirror Content:

ATP Asbury Park Announces More Acts: Ultramagnetic MC’s, Mogwai, The Pop Group and more

Top Story
The Afghan Whigs Reunite to Play Both All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA and UK

Related Charles Bradley Content:

Beale Street Music Festival Announces 2013 Lineup Including The Black Keys, The Flaming Lips, the Smashing Pumpkins and More
Lagunitas SXSW 2015 Day Party Announced
The Daptone Records Super Soul Revue SXSW 2013 Official Showcase Announced Featuring Sharon Jones and Charles Bradley
Charles Bradley & the Menahan Street Band Cover Nirvana
Charles Bradley Announces New Album Victim of Love for April 2013 Release
LISTEN: Charles Bradley Covers Black Sabbath’s “Changes”
Charles Bradley Announces Summer and Fall 2013 Tour Dates
Rolling Stone Rock Room SXSW 2013 Day Parties Announced Featuring Charles Bradley

Soul is in the Heart – Global Soul With Rickey Minor, Stevie Wonder & Friends (Sharon Jones, Janelle Monae, Charles Bradley, Rocky Dawuni, Mia Doi Todd + More)
Charles Bradley, King James & The Special Men, Live at Santa Monica Pier
Charles Bradley – No Time for Dreaming
Charles Bradley – Victim of Love
Charles Bradley Gives the Echo a Lesson In Soul

Related mark lanegan band Content:

LISTEN: Mark Lanegan Band Releases New Song “Harvest Home”
WATCH: Mark Lanegan Performs “Judgement Time” And “I Am Wolf”
Mark Lanegan Band Performs Four Songs for the 4AD Sessions

Related The Afghan Whigs Content:

mxdwn Best of SXSW 2013

LISTEN: The Afghan Whigs Release New Track “The Lottery”
WATCH: The Afghan Whigs Release New Video For “The Lottery”
All Tomorrow’s Parties New Jersey Curated By Greg Dulli 2012 Lineup Announced Featuring The Afghan Whigs, The Roots, Mark Lanegan Band, Louis C.K. And More
Brooklyn Rock Lottery Announces More Bands Including Quicksand, Afghan Whigs, DIIV
Listen: Download The Afghan Whigs New Song “See and Don’t See”
Listen & Download: Free MP3 of The Afghan Whigs Cover of Frank Ocean’s “Lovecrimes”
WATCH: Afghan Whigs Perform “Climax” Live With Usher
Greg Dulli of The Afghan Whigs Announces New Music Coming Soon
WATCH: Afghan Whigs Cover The Police’s “Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic”
Mid Point Music Festival Announces 2014 Lineup Including The Afghan Whigs, Panda Bear and The Raveonettes
The Afghan Whigs Announce Fall 2014 Tour Dates
The Afghan Whigs Announce Summer 2012 Reunion Tour Dates

The Afghan Whigs Live at Bootsy Bellows Los Angeles (Photos, Set List and More)
The Afghan Whigs with Van Hunt Live at the Fonda Theatre, Hollywood

Top Story
Lollapalooza 2012 Lineup Announced Featuring Black Sabbath, The Black Keys, Jack White and More
Watch: Usher Performs With The Afghan Whigs Live At The Fader Fort SXSW 2013