All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA 2012 Day 1 (Frank Ocean, Philip Glass, Tyondai Braxton, Janeane Garofalo and More)

September 22nd, 2012
Goto comments Leave a comment

This is the fifth consecutive year with a full All Tomorrow’s Parties festival here in America, but after proper ATP encampments in the Catskills and 2011’s I’ll Be Your Mirror activities in Asbury Park, New Jersey, the respected promoters and their brand have taken serious critical blows. Financial restructuring in the UK, relocating IBYM 2012 deep in hipster civilization (Pier 36 on Manhattan’s Lower East Side) and a shifting and shrinking lineup—these all threatened to rub the luster off of 2012’s ATP USA before the gates even opened. But even with all of these issues, it does ultimately come down to the music, doesn’t it?
All photos by Adam Blyweiss



In addition to traditions welcome and old (Criterion repertory film) and hopefully new (a whiskey tasting), IBYM’s lineup once again featured comedians. They were wedged onto the festival’s second stage on Friday, a structure itself wedged under the FDR Drive. Despite a small lineup fixed for some time, the performers themselves seemed hastily thrown on stage one after another, in front of a decent-sized crowd that was only slightly less chilly than the oncoming fall weather.


The short narratives of Hannibal Burress (30 Rock, The Eric André Show) were the most consistently laughable. Kurt Braunohler (IFC’s Bunk) was abstract and awkward; headliner Janeane Garofalo was the best-received but prone to take many tangents away from her comedic or political points.



So now we ask, who are these guys pretending to be some sort of rock power-duo? Kicking off the weekend’s proper music on the Pier 36 main stage was the real motherfucking deal, Providence’s Lightning Bolt. More committed fans may be able to discern one LB song from another when performed live, but otherwise—good gracious! This sturdy bass-drums duo filter instruments (and in the case of drummer Brian Chippendale, his voice) so they take on characteristics of everything from death metal to free jazz to jungle. It’s shattered, shattering music reflected in their stage presence, which is really a lack thereof—they play front and center on the floor, crowd surfers threatening to bowl over cymbals and photographers while more thoughtful fans stand close enough to reattach unplugged distortion pedals. Really harsh stuff, it nevertheless easily converts the neophyte.



Edan the Dee Jay (when he’s not Edan the backpack rapper) had the unenviable task of filling a huge gap in Friday’s schedule when Lee Ranaldo canceled a performance art piece due to technical difficulties. Edan appeared to have a nice sized group in front of the stage at all times, even if he started out with Middle Eastern rhythms and progressed through a large chunk of sometimes-mixed music before he hit anything recognizable—the funk classic “Tighten Up” and some Michael Jackson, then Talking Heads and James Brown. He does get serious props for spinning 7-inch singles, a responsibility normally reserved for the big kids of turntablism like DJ Shadow and Cut Chemist.



Performance art wasn’t omitted, though. Philip Glass and Tyondai Braxton may have been sent onstage for only a criminally short time, but that might be chalked up to the brief period they’ve worked together and not a scheduling quirk. In their 30 minutes they best—and first, really—drove home the feel of this as not just any festival, but ATP’s form of grandly understated/overstated weirdness. The young, former Battles veteran and the patriarch of modern American composition plunged the audience into three new etudes. Glass’s Steinway work was supported on the first two by Braxton’s guitar, run through countless filters and coming out sounding like an orchestra. The third and longest piece saw both players eventually banging messy keyboard swords into complementary musical plowshares.






And then lastly there’s Frank Ocean, suddenly thrust far out in front of his prior titles as just a songwriter and just a member of Odd Future Wolf Gang Kill Them All. With a crack team of musicians who looked like they borrowed The Roots’ suits, Ocean’s cool-customer R&B leaned heavily on Channel Orange material but also pulled from his leaks and mixtape tracks. Yes, he’s played with all of Odd Future before; yes, he’s toured on his own; yes, he just did Saturday Night Live. However, playing for a crowd who had just witnessed frenetic art-punk and experimental classical, and commanding that room in spite of rock-star lateness and questionable sound—it may not be what ATP initially planned, but it may have been Ocean’s true arrival as headliner material.






All photos by Adam Blyweiss

Search for All Tomorrow's Parties albums on Amazon

By Adam Blyweiss Posted in Reviews, Show Reviews , , , , , , , , , ,

Related ATP Festival Content:

Interview: The Album Leaf’s Jimmy LaValle on New EP and All Tomorrow’s Parties

Animal Collective to Curate ATP UK Festival
Listen: Yeah Yeah Yeahs Premiere New Single “Sacrilege”
ATP New York Finalizes Lineup, Announces Kurt Vile, GZA and More
Watch: The National Performs New Song “Lola” at All Tomorrow’s Parties 2012
ATP New York Line-up Finalized
Public Enemy, Company Flow Added to ATP Fest Lineup

All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA 2012 Day 3 (Godspeed You! Black Emperor, Autolux, The Make-Up and more)
All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA 2012 Day 1 (Frank Ocean, Philip Glass, Tyondai Braxton, Janeane Garofalo and More)

Related All Tomorrow's Parties Content:

Newest All Tomorrow’s Parties Event Announced, Godspeed You! Black Emperor, Boris, Boredoms Headline
Jeff Mangum Announces New North American Tour Dates
Slint Set to Perform For First Time In Six Years at ATP – End of An Era Festival 2013
All Tomorrow’s Parties Festival Curated By Jeff Mangum Pushed Back to March 2012
All Tomorrow’s Parties Announces End of an Era Festival 2013 Lineup, Television to Play Marquee Moon In Its Entirety Weekend 1
Battles Take A Break From The Studio For Two Live Shows
Medical Issues Cause More Mogwai U.S. Tour Date Postponements
Breeders Reunite To Perform at All Tomorrow’s Parties 2013
All Tomorrow’s Parties Festival NY Announces Line-Up
Buke and Gase Announce New Album General Dome For January 2013 Release
The Residents and More Added to ATP Line-Up
Hot Snakes Announce December 2012 Tour Dates
I’ll Be Your Mirror Festival Acquires Additional Acts and Ticket Option
All Tomorrow’s Parties I’ll Be Your Mirror NJ Moved to New York City
Caribou Offers Vibration Ensemble Live Album for Free Download
All Tomorrow’s Parties The Nightmare Before Christmas 2012 Curated By Shellac Announced
TV on the Radio and Deerhunter To Curate All Tomorrow’s Parties 2013
Jabberwocky Festival Announces Cancellation
All Tomorrow’s Parties 2012 Curated by The National Moved to Pontins Holiday Camp
All Tomorrow’s Parties Announce 2014 Lineup Featuring Portishead, Interpol and More

All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA 2012 Day 2 (The Afghan Whigs, The Roots, Jose Gonzalez, Dirty Three and more)

Top Story
Portishead Announce North American October Tour
All Tomorrow’s Parties Presents I’ll Be Your Mirror in New Jersey

Related Philip Glass Content:

Iggy Pop Added to Tibet House US Benefit Concert
The Flaming Lips, Laurie Anderson And Philip Glass Will Be Part Of The 2015 Tibet House Benefit Concert
Iggy Pop, Joe Walsh and New Order to Perform at Tibet House Benefit Concert
Tibet House Benefit Concert Announces 2013 Lineup Including Philip Glass, Patti Smith, Jim James and More
Original Soundtrack For Upcoming Film Motion Set For February 2013 Release Including Clint Mansell, Philip Glass, and Emily Wells

Related I'll Be Your Mirror Content:

ATP Asbury Park Announces More Acts: Ultramagnetic MC’s, Mogwai, The Pop Group and more

Top Story
The Afghan Whigs Reunite to Play Both All Tomorrow’s Parties: I’ll Be Your Mirror USA and UK

Related Tyondai Braxton Content:

Tyondai Braxton to Perform with Orchestra
Tyondai Braxton Announces New Project Hive to Premiere March 2013 and Spring 2013 Events

Related Lightning Bolt Content:

Lightning Bolt Announce Fall 2012 Tour Dates
WATCH: Pearl Jam Releases Short Film for New Album Lightning Bolt Featuring Judd Apatow and Carrie Brownstein
Listen: Stream Lightning Bolt’s 20-Minute “I Found A Ring in My Ear”
WATCH: Pearl Jam Releases Video of New Song “Sirens”
Watch: The Flaming Lips/Lightning Bolt Release New Video “I’m Working at NASA on Acid”
Second Pearl Jam Countdown Clock Hits Zero to Reveal New Album Lightning Bolt Set for October 2013 Release

Feel the Noise – FYF Fest Day 2 at LA State Historic Park (Review, Photos and More)
Lightning Bolt – Oblivion Hunter

Related frank ocean Content:

High Fidelity
Frank Ocean – channel ORANGE

WATCH: OFWGKTA’s Frank Ocean Debuts New Track, “Super Rich Kids,” Live in LA
Tyler the Creator, Frank Ocean and Toro y Moi Collaborating
Listen: Stream New Song From Frank Ocean Featuring Tyler, The Creator “Golden Girl”
LISTEN: Converse Releases Three Artists, One Song Track Featuring Frank Ocean, Diplo, and Mick Jones & Paul Simonon of The Clash
Frank Ocean Cancels Australian Tour Dates Due to Torn Vocal Cords
Listen & Download: Free MP3 of The Afghan Whigs Cover of Frank Ocean’s “Lovecrimes”
Listen: Frank Ocean Releases Stream of Radiohead Cover of “Fake Plastic Trees”
Watch: Frank Ocean and The Roots Perform “Bad Religion” on Late Night With Jimmy Fallon
Lil B Posts A Photo Claiming He’s In The Studio With Frank Ocean
Jay Z, Kanye West and Frank Ocean Being Sued For Alleged Copyright Infringement
Watch: Video of Frank Ocean’s Entire Set From Day 1 of Coachella 2012

Bonnaroo 2014: Day Four
Photos: Frank Ocean Live at the El Rey

Top Story
Bonnaroo Announces 2014 Lineup Featuring Elton John, Kanye West, Jack White and More
Nominees for 55th Annual Grammy Awards 2013 Announced, Album of the Year Candidates Actually Relevant Including The Black Keys’ El Camino, Mumford & Sons’ Babel, and Jack White’s Blunderbuss
Frank Ocean Reveals Via Tumblr That His First True Love Was A Man

Related Janeane Garofalo Content:

Jeff Mangum to Perform at Occupy Wall Street Telethon “The People’s Bailout,” Event To Stream November 2012